For-profit colleges encourage fraud, government report finds


Overpriced, default, fraud. Sounds like a typical day on Wall Street, right? According to a Government Accountability Office report released last week, these signal a growing trend in the sales and marketing practices of private, for-profit universities.

According to the report, GAO investigators posed as potential students at 15 for-profit colleges in order to find out how colleges that receive billion sin federal Pell Grants and federally subsidized student loans treat their students.

GAO investigators found that all of the colleges made "deceptive and otherwise questionable statements" to them. Four of the colleges encouraged fraudulent practices by the prospective students, including falsification of financial aid forms. Other college representatives violated federal regulations to provide students with accurate information about the length of programs offered, costs, and graduation rates. College staff frequently told applicants they would be in classes for 12 months but quoted prices of tuition for nine moths of classes.

GAO investigators reported that private colleges in California and Texas encouraged students to falsely increase the number of dependents on their financial aid form in order to qualify for grants. Another investigator applying to a Pennsylvania school was told not to report some $250,000 in savings in order to qualify for financial aid. An undercover applicant to a Florida school said they were falsely told that the school was accredited by the same organization as that which had accredited Harvard. Others grossly exaggerated the incomes they would earn after graduation, or implied to students that student loans don't really have to be repaid.

The GAO report noted that student loan default rates for former students of for-profit colleges are much higher than those at public universities and colleges.

GAO investigators who used for-profit college websites to seek more information began receiving high-pressure phone calls within five minutes of their activity on the website. They reported receiving 180 calls in a month from the colleges anxious to get them into their classes.

A comparison between the tuition rates of for-profit colleges and local public universities with the same or similar programs found enormous disparities as well. According to data compiled by GAO investigators, students attending for-profit colleges could expect to pay far more for the same program. For example, a student seeking an associate's degree in respiratory therapy at a for-profit Texas college could pay as much as 19 times more than a student in a similar program at a local publicly operated college. Earning a certificate in web page design at one Pennsylvania for-profit college could cost as much as 10 times more than the same program at a local public college.

The report showed that while some of the staff at these colleges provided accurate and helpful information for prospective students, deceptive or harmful practices were far too frequent. The names of the schools were not disclosed but they were located in Arizona, California, Texas, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Florida and Washington D.C.


Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • Saddleback College, Mission Viejo, CA. Financial aid office director and some staff, hold back financial aid funds from the students who are already approved for aid. last semester, I got financial aid but they had shorted me $300.00 because I took a class they said did not meet the requirement. After stressful sorting out, they sent me a letter saying they had approved the $300.00 but they never deposited it into my higher one account as they should have. And, this semester, which started in August of 2011, they failed to award me the financial aid that was approved for me. I had trouble getting my books, which I desperately needed and books are terrible expensive. If you do not have books you cannot do well in the classes because you cannot study. So, I borrowed funds to get my books and all this time Saddleback colleger did not award the funds to me. After talking to the office earlier in the semester to find out why they have not awarded the funds, I was told that they were told to tell me they could give me any information for four weeks. only today, november 21st, 2011, after I quit because I was so upset, and the semester is almost over, they sent me a letter saying the freeze on my account is off and I am approved. They never told me that there was a freeze on my account and why that would be. There is no date of award on the letter, which means they do not intend to give me the funds. Something should be done about colleges that do not disburse the funds to students that are approved for financial aid to help them through college. Why do the institutions we trust turn bad? How will there be an educated generation tomorrow if these colleges are allowed to hinder their ability to stay in school?

    Posted by Hatch, 11/21/2011 8:39pm (4 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments