Judge scraps farmers’ case against Monsanto


On Mar. 2, a case brought against biotech corporation Monsanto by the Organic Seed Growers and Trade Association - plus 82 other plaintiffs representing around 300,000 farmers - was dismissed, striking a considerable blow to the cause of small farmers.

The plaintiffs had sought a judgment to stop Monsanto from suing them for growing crops containing genes patented by the company. The genes enter crops via cross contamination from wind and other sources.

Monsanto, they say, has reneged on assurances it gave not to sue in cases where patented genes were acquired inadvertently.

U.S. Federal District Judge Naomi Buchwald threw out OSGATA's case, calling its claims "unsubstantiated," and charging that the plaintiffs had exaggerated the magnitude of Monsanto's patent enforcement.

Doug Gurian-Sherman, senior scientist with the Union of Concerned Scientists, disagreed with that ruling. "Beyond whatever happens with the suit," he said, "there are some very legitimate issues behind it. There is already a significant burden [present] to organic food production, and there is more coming. It raises the question: is it possible for organic agriculture to survive in the face of genetically modified crops?"

The farmers on Friday were dissatisfied with Buchwald's ruling. "We're Americans," said Jim Gerritsen, an organic seed farmer and president of OSGATA. "We believe in the system. But we're disappointed in the judge."

Critics of Monsanto note that the corporation has taken nearly every measure possible to stamp out small farmers and dominate the agricultural industry. They have reportedly gone so far as to rely on private investigators, who secretly videotape and photograph farmers, posing as surveyors. Others have been said to confront farmers and try and persuade them to sign papers that would give Monsanto access to their private records.

Farmers have referred to the company's henchmen as "the seed police."

Monsanto recently came out of court with a loss under its belt, after a court in southern France found the company guilty of poisoning cereal farmer Paul Francois, who was hit in the face with fumes from a Monsanto product, subsequently suffering irreversible neurological damage.

Gerritsen noted that this is not over, and that the farmers he represents will organize and continue to fight on.

"The situation that brought us to court [in the first place] is still there. Farmers need the protection of the court. We filed a completely legitimate lawsuit under the Declaratory Judgment Act. We do understand that we have the right to appeal. And that is already underway; the discussions have already begun."

Photos: Monsanto, the world's largest seed maker, have repeatedly harrassed and sued farmers. James A. Finley/AP Photos

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • Once upon a time in central Virginia one could drive from Richmond west towards Charlotteville and see pastures full of livestock and fields full of various crops.
    Take that drive today and you will find a pasture or two with cows or horses and sporadic crop growth. Most folks just raise gardens for their families and even that can be cost prohibitive. What has happened? I was speaking of the late 60's and early 70's and here it is 40 years later and the small farmers have disappeared.
    Want to fight the beast, buy fresh, buy local and buy from farmers who advertise as organic. We have several weekend markets in our area and its an opportunity to meet and greet local growers. FYI...Check out Twin Oaks Intentional Community they have links to organic seed venders they supply seeds to.

    Posted by Mike Greer, 03/14/2012 10:48pm (4 years ago)

  • "Farmers need the protection of the court."

    But this is very difficult when the judiciary system is clearly collaborating with the biggest corporations whose only goal is to make profits. That’s why I think the government shouldn’t allow such a small number of corporations to build monopoly positions in the food industry. I am a great fan of organic food and in <a href="http://ellidavis.com/toronto-real-estate-news/2012/02/organic-living-toronto">Canada organic farming</a> has recently been on the rise and I think that similar steps will have detrimental consequences as far as the future development of this industry sector is concerned. We should take this as a warning to act until it's too late.

    Posted by anthony, 03/10/2012 12:33pm (4 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments