Scientists suggest reason for religion's decline

There are less religious people in America than ever, and that percentage is far higher than in many European countries. A new report tries to explain why, and what future trends could be.

But the report's authors say that more than just decline is in store for religion in some countries. It may be on the verge of extinction in nine nations: Australia, Austria, Canada, the Czech Republic, Finland, Ireland, the Netherlands, New Zealand and Switzerland.

It should be noted that this means the decline in the number of people who claim to adhere to any organized religious group. In surveys, fewer people than previously said that they were Catholics, Protestants, Islamic or any other religion. These numbers do not portray what these people, who no longer consider themselves followers of any particular faith, actually believe. Some are atheists, some are agnostics and some may have other ideas entirely.

Researchers studied the ongoing decline of religion around the world and nationally - the unaffiliated are the fastest growing religious minority in all 50 states of the U.S. - and tried to understand the dynamics responsible for the decline's speed. Instead of trying to find an ideological reason, they looked at religious affiliations as social groupings in society, and tried to set a statistical framework that would allow predictions.

"We have developed a general framework for modeling competition between social groups and analyzed the behavior of the model under modest assumptions," the scientists explained. "We found that a particular case of the solution fits census data on competition between religious and irreligious segments of modern secular societies in 85 regions around the world."

The researchers posited that religions are like any other social group: political party, fraternity and so on, and that people adhere to them if there are benefits. These perks could be either material - better job, standing in the community, friendship - or spiritual - a sense of connection to a higher cause. Generally, the more members a group has, the more benefits, and more people are attracted. This tendency boosts participation - and the converse is also true. A group with fewer members offers less benefits and, consequently, current adherents tend to drift.

Researchers sought to prove that assumption and to come up with a model that could predict future motion.

The results are unlikely to bring joy to the pope or any other spiritual leader: "The model indicates that in these societies the perceived utility of religious non-affiliation is greater than that of adhering to a religion, and therefore predicts continued growth of non-affiliation, tending toward the disappearance of religion."

Priests, rabbis and imams shouldn't fold up their tent just yet, though. While the science behind the study - nonlinear dynamics - has been used to accurately predict which languages will die out and which will not, and when, religious identification is perhaps even more complex.

The current model suggests only two groups that compete for adherents: the religious and the non-religious. Further, it assumes a complete uniformity of society, not taking into account geographical distributions and the impact of other divisions.

One of the researchers, Dr. Richard J. Wiener, told the American Physical society yesterday that he and his colleagues were working to strengthen the model. Still, Wiener told the BBC, the findings of the original report are "a suggestive result."

Will religion actually become extinct? God only knows.

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • Religion has created and/or caused most conflicts, killings, judgements, divisiveness amongst peoples than anything on earth. In time, societies will look back at today and think, "how could those people have believed such things and committed the atrocities and such?"
    Good riddance! bring on the peace.

    Posted by Kyle, 12/15/2013 7:08am (2 years ago)

  • It's time for religion to fold up its tabernacle and head for the wilderness. That at least is protected area now. The mess religions have left behind in civilization will have to be left to science to clean up. The disgrace they can take with them.

    Posted by , 03/26/2013 3:53am (3 years ago)

  • Mental health experts have identified religion as a mental disorder. Therapy will probably be available for the remaining believers within a decade.

    Posted by mark, 12/23/2012 10:13am (3 years ago)

  • That final line is gold, great post.

    Posted by Emily Cayford, 08/23/2012 8:49pm (3 years ago)

  • Dear Mr. Margolis, it's "fewer" religious people, not "less."

    Posted by Richard Steele, 08/10/2012 2:17pm (3 years ago)

  • While quite obviously people subscribe to some form of religion or other for the benefits ~ from social acceptance to a berth in some sort of heaven ~ those who don't subscribe to a religion have nothing to gain in physical (or metaphysical) terms.

    Though the growth of modern learning and communication must play a large part in the abandonment of religion, the major cause, given the ingrained instincts of the human animal, is most certainly the undeniable discovery that religion's promises of personal gain are a hoax.

    That's why we no longer shop around for a better religious deal as has long been the case; more and more we know that there's no gain to be had.

    Posted by Jason Wreight, 03/15/2012 8:55pm (4 years ago)

  • I am a former catholic who just can't accept a lot of the medieval nonsense (read: saint/relic worship, purgatory, use of holy water, infant baptisms, the 7 sacraments, original sin. etc.) the church teaches, and, I can't see why anybody with more than an 8th grade education can.

    Posted by jon jay, 02/23/2012 7:40pm (4 years ago)

  • Any God that would allow the world of today is an evil one

    Posted by Bob, 01/29/2012 8:55pm (4 years ago)

  • It's not God or Christ I have a problem with, it's their fan club.

    I still believe in a higher power. I'm not sure what this power is, what it does, or it's role in the universe; but I feel the tug of this energy everyday. the common thread that binds all of us together.

    However, I do not follow the dogma, fear, and hatred of religion. I will not allow another human being to define my relationship with the divine not will I ever define it for another. It is what it is and it is a mystery that is meant to be discovered not shoved down our throats.

    Posted by EMH, 04/18/2011 12:14pm (5 years ago)

  • Please submit names of people you come across, and send them to the FBI for backround checks. Then you'll see how compassionate and understanding they really are.

    Posted by hideunderarock, 04/11/2011 4:06pm (5 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments