Senate filibuster deal a capitulation, says Common Cause


WASHINGTON - Today's announced "compromise" on Senate filibuster reform is in fact a capitulation by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, who now has missed two excellent opportunities to restore the Senate to its proper role as a working legislative body, Common Cause said.

"My friend Harry Reid, the senator from Searchlight, NV, has gone missing in the fight for filibuster reform," said Common Cause President Bob Edgar. "The deal he and Sen. McConnell have struck allows individual senators to continue blocking debate and action by the entire body and to do so without explaining themselves to their colleagues or the American people. This is not the Senate of debate and deliberation our founders envisioned.

Edgar invited senators who remain committed to ending the 60-vote requirement for conducting most Senate business to join in Common Cause's lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the filibuster rule. The case is before the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington following a lower court judge's ruling in December that Common Cause and other plaintiffs, including four members of the House of Representatives, lacked legal standing to sue.

"We're convinced that in a trial on the merits, we can demonstrate that the filibuster is unconstitutional and was never contemplated by America's founders," Edgar said. "The Constitution requires a supermajority for Senate action in just a handful of circumstances, including ratification of treaties and convicting the President in an impeachment trial, but the filibuster has expanded that to cover virtually every piece of legislation and every judicial or executive branch nomination."

Edgar praised and congratulated Sens. Jeff Merkley and Tom Udall, whose determined drive for changes to the filibuster rule brought the issue to prominence and pushed Reid and McConnell to act, as well as Sen. Tom Harkin, who for more than a decade has championed filibuster reform.

"These senators and others have given the reform effort their best shot but through no fault of their own have come up short," he said. "It's now clear that the Senate will not fix the filibuster and the President lacks authority to fix it. We must turn to the judicial branch to enforce the Constitution."

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • Senators Tom Harkin, Jeff Merkley and Tom Udall, deserve our utmost support for their effort to stop the right wing from derailing the everyday business of Congress.

    Unfortunately, the over compromising Harry Reid, who talks tough but when it comes down to the fight doesn't have the record, has done it again.

    Our president has learned from the bruising of his first term. Unfortunately Reid hasn't.

    The proposed legislation introduced by Merkley and Udall would have made it "inconvenient" for the right --tea par tiers-- to just throw in the monkey wrench and go about their business. It would have required them to defend their positions on the floor for hours or even days. And that would mean they could miss a week end at home.

    When will the Dems ever learn!

    wage peace
    stop the right wing

    Posted by , 01/29/2013 6:17am (3 years ago)

  • Harry Reed is a disgrace to his party and should pay for his continued capitulation!

    Posted by Arthur Howard, 01/26/2013 7:22am (3 years ago)

  • Harry Reid is a weak sister and should have been dumped by the voters a long time ago!

    Posted by Frank M. Phelan, 01/24/2013 5:15pm (3 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments