The roots of Tucson


While Rush Limbaugh and his cohorts continue to vigorously deny it, the Tucson shootings were a political crime. The target was a Democratic congressperson, not a Republican or a random authority figure. She is also Jewish, female and a previous victim of political violence. In the racist, hate-filled atmosphere of Arizona politics, her right-wing extremist opponent in the November election had called on supporters to bring M-16 rifles to one of his campaign rallies.

The violence in Tucson is also not an isolated incident. According to the last figures issued by the FBI, there were 8,336 victims of hate crimes committed by 6,225 people in 2009. The victims in these statistics were overwhelmingly African-Americans, Hispanics and other minorities, immigrants, Jews, Muslims or people thought to be Muslims, gays and lesbians and people with disabilities. Not included were many others such as abortion providers, Democratic office holders and government agencies.

Some victims have also been safety officers, including the security guard at the Holocaust museum, the police officers in Pittsburgh who faced an anti-Obama fanatic and the California highway patrolmen injured in a shootout with a man egged on by Glenn Beck's ravings against the Tides Foundation.

The perpetrators of nearly all these crimes, which come to some 10,000 yearly nationwide, are not Muslim terrorists or leftists. They are overwhelmingly white males motivated by racism and right-wing extremism. That is a fact of life that no amount of denial by Limbaugh and company can hide.

In the aftermath of Tucson there is a healthy discussion about mental health services, gun control and political civility. But to deal with the problem it is necessary to go further and identify and expose its cause. The Department of Homeland Security attempted to do this in a report on the rise of right-wing extremism issued in April 2009, but instead of a congressional investigation, the report was shouted down by the Republicans and Fox News.

Since the 1930s the Republican Party has been the main party of the rich and big business. Since the 1960s and, especially since President Nixon's Southern Strategy, it has been the party of racism. Now, in the more recent period and especially since the election of President Obama, it has also become the party of right-wing extremism, including extremist violence.

The Tucson attack has taken some wind out of the GOP sails. The Republicans were forced to postpone the vote to repeal the health care reform and support for repeal has plummeted, including among Republican voters. The Republicans in the House have been left holding the bag, while support for the reform has risen. Honest policy differences were never the motivation in any case. The repeal effort has mainly been driven by hatred for the nation's first African-American president. Health care reform was to be his "Waterloo" and repeal or sabotage of the bill is part of the GOP's prime goal of destroying his presidency and preventing his re-election.

But there are signs the tide has turned. Tucson has opened a lot of eyes. Obama's handling of the attack has won high marks, while the ultra-right's mascot candidate, Sarah Palin, has suffered a huge setback.

Obama made an inspiring speech at the memorial service in Tucson, but his warning not to point fingers or assign blame should not be used to dampen criticism of the danger of right-wing extremism. To do that would be a grave disservice to the victims.

Yes, there must be greater unity and civility. Yes, there must be more support for mental health programs. Yes, there must be far stricter gun control.

But there must also be recognition that it is right-wing extremism that opposes all these things, that it constitutes the main danger to the safety and security of the people, to their economic wellbeing and their democratic rights. The best way to honor the victims of Tucson and prevent a similar occurrence is to soundly defeat the Republicans in 2012.

Image: Andrew Ressa // CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • The Republican Party and the so-called "Tea Party" are riding an express train to fascism and intimidation through violence is the essence of fascist activism.

    On the positive side, the election of a Republican House of Representives may prove fortunate insofar as, with a Democratic President and Senate, they really can't pass any legislation, but they can show the American people, especially the "independents", how crazy they really are.

    And I think that the next time Republican candidates start talking about "locking and loading" and "Second
    Amendment remedies", the American people are going to come down on them like a ton of bricks.

    Posted by John Whiskey, 01/24/2011 10:30pm (5 years ago)

  • I agree with some of the other people about this news.

    Posted by charms, 01/21/2011 12:50am (5 years ago)

  • Brother Rick,your work has been exemplary as a correspondent for the peoplesworld and its predecessors for over forty years. The present writer met you over thirty years ago during a Hall-Tyner election drive.
    More,your work in Ohio as representative for working class communities and labor has also been a model for those who fight for workers everywhere and love our working people and country.
    But in this analytic piece,concluding that the "best" way to prevent fascistic atrocities like Tucson is to "...soundly defeat the Republicans in 2012." It seems,does not give our working people the tools of analysis we need to bring together more and more people to even soundly defeat the Republicans in 2012.
    As you accurately point out,our president Obama urges,unity,civility,with no finger pointing. You urge,recognition,criticism of right wing extremism,increasing safety through economic security and democratic rights.
    We,in good conscience have to agree with the president and you Rick,AS FAR AS YOU HAVE GONE with this analysis.
    But as historian Norman Markowitz (see Markowitz's 1/11/11 The Arizona Murders and the Politica Culture of Fascism in PA)has instructed us,to analyze our present threat of fascism in present day U.S. condition, we have find out HOW WE GOT TO THIS JUNCTURE and HOW WE STOKE THE FREEDOM PROCESSES OF EXTRICATING OURSELVES and fellows from this fascist,literally murderous state of affairs,for all,communists,leftists,centrists,democracts,children and citizens and non-citizens,in general.
    According to Markowitz the roots of fascism,as a mass or people problem is violence directed at national citizenry(and immigrants,non-citizenry),the sick "enemies within" thesis, targeting little children(lest we forget fascism in Germany killed 1.5 million children) and congresspersons,and let's not forget socialists and communists.
    All these projected "enemies within"not least of which are Democrats-ask the children victims of Nazi fascism and those millions today,along with nine year old Christina Taylor Green,in the U.S., who you well know rot in racist,crumbling,ghettos,barrios and slums,too many dying from gun violence,also,with little or no prospects for jobs or education.
    It is on this basis of deeper understanding and analysis that we must attack the social basis of American fascism,not just to defeat"extremist Republicans"and emplace"Democrats"but to coalesce to halt,with an all peoples unity to stop the over thirty years of racism and reaction,at its roots,the capitalist economic violence of universal selfishness,street violence,drugs,alchohol,domestic violence,gangs,guns,war and reaction filled anathema leading to fascism,including Nixonomics,Reaganomics,and the later Bushesnomics-U.S. style(with international connections),which you may agree-constitute "The roots of Tucson".

    Posted by E.E.W. Clay, 01/20/2011 3:26pm (5 years ago)

  • AMEN !

    Posted by Leandro DellaPiana, 01/20/2011 3:08pm (5 years ago)

  • From 1949 to 1987, the Fairness Doctrine was a crucial element in keeping the public airwaves within some framework of honest discourse. The hateful babble by rabble who know exactly what they're doing has turned civil debate into civil war....with sickening consequences.

    Posted by RDC, 01/20/2011 2:08pm (5 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments