Union official scores Republican ad featuring fake coal miner

fake miner

A regional vice president of the United Mine Workers of America has condemned a new Republican TV ad airing in coal country because it features a coal executive masquerading as a miner.

In the ad, Heath Lovell, the vice president of River View Coal in Kentucky, accuses incumbent Democratic congressional representatives and President Obama of trying to destroy the coal industry. Lovell is wearing a t-shirt, bib overalls and a coal miner's helmet with no mention made of his position as a coal company executive.

"I've never seen anything so appalling and deceitful from the coal industry and from the Republican campaign," said Steve Earle, a regional vice president of the UMWA in Kentucky. "You have a pencil pusher acting like a coal miner."

The Romney campaign is running the ad also in the Western part of Virginia, which like much of Kentucky, West Virginia and Ohio, is part of "coal country." Romney is behind in the polls in Virginia and Ohio with conventional wisdom being that he must win one, if not both of those states in order to get on a path to victory in the Electoral College.

In the ad running in Kentucky, Lovell talks about the decline of coal trains in the Congressional District represented by Democratic U.S. Rep. Ben Chandler. Lovell, who has endorsed Chandler's Republican opponent Andy Barr, says Chandler, President Obama and the Environmental Protection Agency "are destroying us.. They are putting the coal industry out of business, and it's just devastating."

Lovell has officially contributed $2,500 to Romney's campaign.

The UMWA is supporting the Democrat, Chandler, because of his efforts to promote safety in the mines. "If the UMWA did not think Ben Chandler was pro-coal, then we wouldn't have endorsed his campaign," said Earle, adding, "Andy Barr is so out of touch with Central Kentucky that he had to bring in an outsider who is a coal company executive and Republican donor to masquerade as a blue collar worker from Estill County."

Many in the region, including the union that represents coal miners, have expressed concern over the effect of EPA regulations on the industry but they do not consider those regulations or job safety regulations designed to protect miners as the main cause of the coal industry's problems.

They understand that exploitation of cheaper than ever natural gas by the nation's utility giants is much more to blame than EPA regulations. Natural gas was supplanting coal as America's source of electricity all through the years of the Bush presidency. What has occurred during the Obama years, they understand, is only a continuation of an established trend.

Post your comment

Comments are moderated. See guidelines here.


  • He's a Coal Miner. I was a Home Builder. I hired labor to build homes for me. Nothing ignoble in being a business owner and providing work and sutenance for those unwilling to take the finacial risks and responsibilites inherent in being the 'big boss man'. I was a carpenter. It was a means to an end. I ended up retired and (for the hopefully long moment until the dollar tanks) finacially secure at 46 in 2006. I took the risks and reaped the rewards. If energy policy harms that executive Coal Miner, it will surely harm his labor force more. Who else did you expect to speak up for this industry, the guys who got their high school girlfriend pregnant at sixteen and bitch about their lot in life at the local beer joint after every shift's end. They pulled that lot when they didn't excersise self control and walked into the mine to pay for diapers and their cheap domestic beer .

    Posted by Scott Madsen, 09/25/2012 9:29am (3 years ago)

  • Thank you for covering this issue.
    A formal complaint has now been filed about this with the Federal Election Commission by Progress Ohio. See http://www.progressohio.org/blog/2012/09/progressohio-files-fec-complaint-against-romney-mining-company.html

    Posted by Anita Waters, 09/25/2012 7:13am (3 years ago)

  • Tom Smith, Republican challenger for the Senate from PA runs an ad claiming to have been a union miner & showing him in an underground mine, while his entire background is in surface mining.

    Posted by Working Class Heroes, 09/21/2012 10:21pm (3 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments